Notice: The Courts of the Ninth Circuit website is currently undergoing migration to a new platform. You have been redirected here while the migration is completed. The full manuals are available to browse here.
You are here
8.196 Failure to Appear or Surrender—Affirmative Defense
8.196 FAILURE TO APPEAR OR SURRENDER—AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
(18 U.S.C. § 3146(c))
It is a defense to a charge of failure to [appear] [surrender] if uncontrollable circumstances prevented the person from [appearing] [surrendering]. In order to establish this defense, the defendant must prove that the following elements are more probably true than not true:
First, uncontrollable circumstances prevented the defendant from [appearing] [surrendering];
Second, the defendant did not contribute to the creation of the circumstances in reckless disregard of the requirement to [appear] [surrender]; and
Third, the defendant [appeared] [surrendered] as soon as the uncontrollable circumstances ceased to exist.
If you find that each of these elements is more probably true than not true, you must find the defendant not guilty.
Comment
See United States v. Springer, 51 F.3d 861, 866-68 (9th Cir.1995) (discussing the "uncontrollable circumstances" prong).
File:
